Makita Vs. Bosch Cordless Impact Driver Comparison
Disclosure: Our work is supported by affiliate commissions — Learn more.
One of the biggest problems power tool buyers face is to buy the right product at the right amount. The last thing you want is to end up with an unreliable tool. It is why we compare Makita vs. Bosch impact drivers to see what each has to offer.
Both Makita and Bosch brands have been around for decades now. Over that whole period, they know what makes a good impact driver. If you are new to such tools, always consider the durability, ease of control, the power delivery, among other features.
The Makita XDT16Z model is all about giving you more features at the price. It comes with new features aimed at improving the overall performance of the power tool. The same goes for the Bosch model as it also has a brushless motor aimed at improving the power delivery, but using less energy. Both models are easy to control.
We find that they are slightly different in terms of the modes of operation as the Makita model has more speed settings than the Bosch IDH182-02 model. Let us see what are the other features you will like about the two models below.
Makita XDT16Z And Bosch IDH182-02 Impact Drivers | Details Review
Makita XDT16Z 18V LXT Cordless Impact Driver
Makita has a legacy of being an innovative company. That is something we see with this model. It has more speed settings, more power, and other performance capabilities. Here are more features you should learn about.
The manufacturer made this XDT16Z unit to be compact and ergonomic. Such a design leaves you with a lightweight model having a smaller footprint. If you have to work on several projects, it will be easy to fit in your toolbox and carry it around. It weighs only 3.4 lbs. without the battery.
As part of the new technologies, the unit has the Assist Mode and two Tightening Modes. With these modes, they help eliminate cases of screw cam-out and cross threading. That is not all as you still get up to four speed modes to choose from. Depending on what you are working on, it is easy to cycle through the various speed modes.
As for the power, the brushless motor delivers smooth power all the time at different speeds. So, no matter which mode you choose, you will always experience better power delivery. With a max speed of 3600 RPM and torque of 1,600 in. lbs., it should be an ideal tool for multiple projects for a professional.
Whenever using an impact driver, you need more control over the tool. The design and power delivery makes it easy for you to control the impact driver. You should now have an easier time working on delicate projects that need better precision.
What We Like
- Delivers on more energy efficiency
- You get up to 4 speed settings
- The tool is highly durable
- It is easy to control it for better precision
What We Don’t Like
- Batteries and charger not included
The Solution: As much as it does not come with the batteries and charger, ordering them is still easy. Always get them from the same manufacturer to experience the best performance.
Bosch IDH182-02 Cordless Impact Driver
The Bosch IDH182-02 cordless impact driver is for users who want the job done in time and correctly. It is why it comes with an impressive amount of power and other necessary features as mentioned below.
Versatile for different types of work
Upon lifting this unit, you might think it is too small to do much. However, that is where you are wrong. The unit packs quite the punch with its brushless motor. The motor allows for the delivery of more power while at the same time remain efficient.
With this unit, you will get up to 3 speed settings. The low speed setting is for simple work as at this point it delivers 400 inches per pound of torque. The second level is for controlling screws and getting them tightened right. If you want to handle heavy duty tasks, go for the third level, which is the fastest. It also has a maximum power of 1650 in. lbs.
Cell and motor protection
Another feature that perfectly completes this unit should be the cell and motor protection. The aim is to protect the motor and batteries from cases of overheating and overloading. These are common problems whenever using power tools for extended periods. That is not something to worry about whenever using this model.
Ease of control
Whenever you work with an impact driver, you want it to be easy to control. Luckily, that is what you get with this one. It is compact and lightweight. Its length is 6.2 inches and weighs 3.2 pounds. It is a perfect tool for most home DIYers. The rubber grip also makes the tool fit in your hand for proper control.
LED lighting system
Another feature we like is the LED lighting system. Considering that you might end up working in places with less light, it is always best to choose a unit with LED lighting. The bright LED lights on this unit are strategically placed so that you have a better illumination of the workspace.
What We Like
- The brushless motor delivers more power and battery life
- It is versatile as it combines two tools in one
- Impressive maximum torque
- Designed to prevent cases of overheating and overloading
What We Don’t Like
- The battery drains faster with the LED lights ON
The Solution: It is understandable that batteries can drain faster whenever you use the LED lights all the time. To solve this, it is best to only use the lights when necessary to extend the battery life.
Which Is Better?
The Makita model has amazing features for its price point. What makes it stand out should be the four speed modes, allowing you to work on various projects as compared to the Bosch model. Also, it is a compact unit on overall as compared to the Bosch unit. This means that it gives you more control.
The Bosch model on the other hand comes with cell and motor protection. This keeps the unit from overloading and overheating.
Between the two, we find the Makita model being better value for money and the one you should choose.
You should never end up with a unit that does not deliver quality performance after spending your hard-earned money. Both models we have reviewed above are great for various applications. Depending on your needs, then you can go for either of them. For a professional working on tough jobs, the Makita is a great option. However, if you like working on DIY projects at home, then the Bosch unit is still ideal.